.30 Caliber Gas Checks

  • 270 Views
  • Last Post 1 weeks ago
  • Topic Is Solved
BudHyett posted this 2 weeks ago

Has anyone done a live-fire comparison between Hornady and Gator checks? 

If so, what were the results? 

Country boy from Illinois, living in the Magical Pacific Northwest

Attached Files

Order By: Standard | Newest | Votes
res45 posted this 2 weeks ago

I've used lots of the Hornady checks from many years before switching to the Gator checks mainly due to cost. I honestly can't tell any difference between the two.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • BudHyett
  • RicinYakima
MarkinEllensburg posted this 2 weeks ago

I'm looking at Sage's Outdoors currently. Their prices seem much more reasonable. So to add on to Bud's question has anyone done a side by side comparison of these to Hornady?

I'm buying gaschecks for three shooters in my family that shoot .30 caliber. Checks are getting much to expensive.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • BudHyett
Coydog posted this 2 weeks ago

I had used Lyman press on then Hornady seen a differences on the 2 and then I went to Gators then I seen they work the same as Hornady . they both clip on . And Gators are less for cost. 

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • BudHyett
R. Dupraz posted this 2 weeks ago

I started with Hornady GC's but switched to Gator check's several years ago, also because of the cost. And the only difference that I have found is that the Gators are noticeably harder. The last copper GC's came from Sages which from what I understand are actually Gators anyway. 

Five years ago or so, I ordered direct from Gator. At that time, no postage on 5000 or more. At one time the military crew around here put an order together for 50,000 Gators direct to take advantage of that.

 

R

 

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • BudHyett
Rich/WIS posted this 2 weeks ago

Started with Lyman, then went Hornady, and now use Gators from Sage.  If there was a difference between Hornady and Sage I never saw it, but will caveat that with neither I nor my rifles are good enough to tell if there was a difference in accuracy. Do know that my rifles did NOT like AL gas checks, used to find them on the ground in front of the firing line.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • BudHyett
BudHyett posted this 1 weeks ago

Aluminum in pure metal has an irregular crystalline structure. This leads to edges with sharp points that erode any metal that it contacts. Aluminum oxide is used in sanding belts to take advantage of the charismatic. 

This anomaly is why I will never shoot anything aluminum in my barrels. Winchester Silvertip Hollowpoint ammunition uses aluminum that does not touch the bore and that is as far as I will go.

Country boy from Illinois, living in the Magical Pacific Northwest

Attached Files

John Alexander posted this 1 weeks ago

As noted by R above Gators are harder.  The extra force to size caused the noses on some soft bore riding bullets to upset to a larger random diameter - not good.  Switched to Hornady to cure problem.  Less likely with hard alloy bullets but something to watch for. 

Another thing that could possibly be a problem is because they are harder they will spring back more after sizing in place and could be more likely to come off. I have not noticed that problem but.

I have several thousand Gators so am looking for the best way to anneal.

John

Attached Files

R. Dupraz posted this 1 weeks ago

I have had and still have the same concerns that John has not so much with nose expansion when sizing but more so with spring back of those hard Gators. Don't know for sure but wonder about the possibility of some occasionally coming  off and creating those wild unexplained flyers.. Especially at 200. 

Some of the crew around here anneal those CK's. But my one and only attempt at this witchcraft was not a success by any stretch so just abandoned the idea and shoot them as is.

After all, no possible way that it  could be the shooter's fault ! 

 

R. 

 

Attached Files

John Alexander posted this 1 weeks ago

As long as a shooter isn't getting much nose expansion from upset OK.  But last week it sneaked up on me and one of the noses was big enough to prevent chambering which ended the shooting session. I have not been able to find an expanded nose since I switched back to Hornadys. The resistance of the handle of the press used for lubing is quite noticeable.

You are right about fliers never being the shooters fault.

John

Attached Files

res45 posted this 1 weeks ago

The good thing about Sage is you don't have to buy a thousand gas checks if you just want to try something out.  You can buy as little as 250 checks at a time if you like or buy a variety to test out.

Attached Files

Close