Whats The Best Shooting Pistol Caliber

  • 9.8K Views
  • Last Post 18 February 2009
Scott Merchant posted this 13 April 2008

I have a rifle model of a 73 Winchester “Uberti” in 44-40 that will put them in a raged hole at 50 yards, and into 11/2 inches at 100 yards. This is with buckhorn sights. The load is 8 grains of Unique and a RCBS 44-200-FN sized at .429.

Scott

I should have stated in lever actions, not in pistols

Attached Files

Order By: Standard | Newest | Votes
corerf posted this 18 February 2009

I am very fond of the 38/357 family. Recoil is moderate, accuracy is high pending the gun. I have had some wicked groups at 25 yds with 158 gr SWC and H-Universal, both in revolver and TC Contender. Thats with hunting loads. I have not tried a reduced target load that's not pushing the bullet to max pressure. I think for all around shooting though the 429 diam. rounds win for energy, accuracy and BC. They get it done in all categories very well.

Attached Files

AMMOe posted this 17 February 2009

I vote for the 44 Special. I have a 1930-built S&W 2nd Hand Ejector that will shoot far better than I can hold with just about any sane load.~AMMOe

Attached Files

Burris posted this 17 February 2009

That's what I like to see, ---a well manicured thumb:cool:

Attached Files

ddeuce43 posted this 27 August 2008

Several years ago I had Hensley & Gibbs make me a custom 4 cavity mould.  It is a replica of the original .44-40 WCF bullet.  Weight about 205 Grains from Whl Wts and drops from the mould about .430” diameter.  Shot it a lot in cowboy action matches, real accurate in .44 SPL revolver with 5.0 grains of WW-231..

One day I broke down and bought a Marlin Century Limited in 44-40 with ballard rifling.  You know, just one of those things I could not help doing.  In W-W brass, 7.2 grains WW-231, WLP, this bullet would shoot one ragged hole at 50 yards and it was almost like magic how it would shoot trick shots like splitting the bullet on an axe blade, cutting string etc.

I kinda felt guilty banging that Century Limited around at Cowboy Matches so I bought a UBERTI Yellow Boy in 44-40 at Winter Range and took it home.  I dropped the powder Charge to 7.0 Grains and the same bullet.  Boy, this thunderstick really shot well.  One afternoon I was out shooting 200 yards and just for grins sent off three rounds at 200 yards from the Uberti.  Two bullet holes were touching and the third was about three inches to the right.  Not bad at 200 yards for a short range rifle.

It is the Indian, not the bow or the arrow that decides where the arrow strikes.

 

Attached Files

CB posted this 21 June 2008

I shoot many of the same calibers in my T/C Contender Pistols as my Marlin Lever guns use.

30/30, 444 Marlin and 45-70. So these are the most versatile rilfe and pistol rounds for me.

Hoepefully soon I will have my T/C 35 Remington Barrel in, I sent it to be “Magna Ported".

 

Jerry

 

 

 

 

Attached Files

Ed Harris posted this 12 June 2008

My brother has one.  Basic load is 3.5 grs. of Bullseye in Starline brass with WSP primer, soft bullets from 98 to 120 grs. at 10-12 BHN sized .314” with Lee Liquid Alox, Saeco #322, #325, Lyman #3118, RCBS 32-98SWC, NEI #82 plainbase all work fine.

Velocity runs 1000 or so in a revolver and 1250 in the rifle.  Inch groups at 25 yards with irons in the Marlin and 2 inches or less with the revolver and my old eyeballs.

73 de KE4SKY In Home Mix We Trust From the Home of Ed's Red in "Almost Heaven" West Virginia

Attached Files

6pt-sika posted this 10 June 2008

I came across two loads Brian Pierce had published in “Handloader” awhile back .

 

One is for the 32-20 , the Lyman 311316 with 12.5 grains of H-110 . I hope to give this one a try on paper before uhmm hunting season gets here .

 

Also in the 32 H&R MAG , the Lyman 311316 bullet with 11 grains of H-110 .

 

He claims the 32-20 load will be about 1900 fps in a 24” barreled rifle . And his data for the 32 MAG was shot in a SIngle Six and he says 1200 fps , so if I shoot that load in my little Marlin 1894CB that is 32 H&R MAG and has a 20” pipe I expect it to be over 1600 fps .

.>

Attached Files

KenK posted this 06 June 2008

This is what looks to be a good load that I just lucked into.  I bought the Blue Dot for another project, it didn't work for that so I tried in in the Marlin 44 magnum.  It is a load Alliant has published for the 44-40.  Saeco 429 10 grains Blue Dot.

Shot with a rest at 50 yards with aperture sights, front and rear.

 

Attached Files

KenK posted this 15 April 2008

I have never used magnum primers.  I mostly use cci small rifle primers but have tried pistol primers which didn't make any noticeable difference.

BTW, I do not crimp.  The powder will keep the bullet from pushing back into the case.

Attached Files

RicinYakima posted this 15 April 2008

KenK, I just happen to have 50 fired Starline cases and about 2 oz. of H322 left. I will try your load. I worked with AA2200 surplus when it was available, and it had lots of unburned powder, but accuracy was very poor. I'm kind of assuming that you are using SR Mag primers? Ric

Attached Files

linoww posted this 15 April 2008

KenK wrote: Ha!  Thats my .44 Magnum/leveraction/cast bullet load!

Intersting how people come up with these weird combinations miles apart.I'd never think of it.

 

George

"if it was easy we'd let women do it" don't tell my wife I said that!

Attached Files

KenK posted this 15 April 2008

Ha!  Thats my .44 Magnum/leveraction/cast bullet load!

Attached Files

linoww posted this 15 April 2008

 

I've been trying for a couple years now to get someone to try my 32-20 load.

Stuff as much H-322 in there as will fit (lightly compressed) with any jacketed or cast bullet between 85 and 120 grains.

Yeah, it will leave some unburned powder in the barrel but I've shot over a  

My buddy Bob Mills pet load for the 357 mag in a singleshot Ruger rifle is all the 4198 the case will hold with a 250g bullet long seated.More powder goes out the barrel than burns<G> and it only goes 950 fps,but will shoot into 1” much of the time.

George

"if it was easy we'd let women do it" don't tell my wife I said that!

Attached Files

KenK posted this 15 April 2008

Scott Merchant wrote:  BUT please post data we like lots of data...Scott  

I've been trying for a couple years now to get someone to try my 32-20 load.

Stuff as much H-322 in there as will fit (lightly compressed) with any jacketed or cast bullet between 85 and 120 grains.

Yeah, it will leave some unburned powder in the barrel but I've shot over a hundred rounds (over a week long period) between cleanings without accuracy falling off.

It will give you 1200-1400 fps out of a 22” barrel, depending on the bullet.

Attached Files

6pt-sika posted this 15 April 2008

Scott Merchant wrote:  Oh by the way I do buy into such thinks as inherently accurate cartridges hence the 222 Rem, 6mm PPC and 6.5x284 and a whole list of others. Scott  

 

I've been down the road with the 222 , 6PPC , 204 and most of the Short Mags . And they have all shot great . Also the 260 REM has been a great performer accuracy and killing wise for me in the past . Granted my experience with all these has been with jacketed bullets .

 

Attached Files

linoww posted this 15 April 2008

If you count a Ruger #1 as a lever action I would add my CHP #1A  .357 magnum as being pretty accurate.Good light loads with RN bullets can go well under 1” at 50 yds and heavy bullet loads(225-280g) shoot into 1.5” (on occasion sub- MOA)at 100.This is with a 4X Leupold so I am cheating.I think the ,357 will shoot with the best of them all being equal.

George

"if it was easy we'd let women do it" don't tell my wife I said that!

Attached Files

Scott Merchant posted this 15 April 2008

gio

I should have posted the title of this more clearly than I did, This about lever action rifles that shoot pistol rounds. I have been loading for the 44-40, 38-40,32-20 and 25-20 for over 30 years and the wives tail about them being more of a problem is bull. :shock:  When I started reloading  steel dies was all I could afford so everything was lubed, didn't know any deferents. Now with all the spray lubes on the market all I do is turn the box's over on a flat surface and spray not much of a bother. On top of it I load all this rounds on a 550 Dillon Press.

As far as the rounds go in my experience the 44-40 has shown to be a inherently accurate cartage, out of the 5 that I own and the many that friends own. My two reasons for making the post are 1. has other shooter experience this or  number 2. tell which round you think is maybe more inherently accurate, BUT please post data we like lots of data and pic's to. Oh by the way I do buy into such thinks as inherently accurate cartridges hence the 222 Rem, 6mm PPC and 6.5x284 and a whole list of others. Scott

Attached Files

6pt-sika posted this 15 April 2008

Lefty wrote: A new Marlin 32 H&R Mag just showed up on the local gun store's rack.  Any experience with one of these?

I have one of these . Although I must admit I have not put a great amount of work in it !

 

It took almost two years to get it after Marlin announced it ! They seemed to drag their feet about getting them out to the consumer .

 

Anyway I have taken it to the range a few times and loaded it with variouse cast bullets that I would shoot in a 32-20 . I had a box of Hornady swaged 90 grain SWC's that I had purchased a few years ago and I have shot them in it . They seemed to cycle thru the action fine and shot rather well with Unique . Also tried the Lyman 311419 and 311316 in it a bit .

They all shot well enough , and with three grains of Unique and the 311419 it makes a decent squirrel rifle .

Attached Files

Lefty posted this 15 April 2008

A new Marlin 32 H&R Mag just showed up on the local gun store's rack.  Any experience with one of these?

Attached Files

44 Flattop posted this 14 April 2008

I really enjoy my .44 Marlin Cowboys.   Pretty accurate too!  But my wifes old (1978) Marlin in .357 may be the most accurate of all!

44

Attached Files

Show More Posts
Close